MINUTES OF THE PLANNING AND GENERAL PURPOSES COMMITTEE

HELD AT EPPING HALL ON TUESDAY 26TH FEBRUARY 2008

 

 

PRESENT:              Councillors: K. Avey (Chairman), J.A. Smith, R. Macrae, J. Lewis, N. Hines (Town Mayor) and B.D.Murphy  (Deputy Town Mayor)

 

IN ATTENDANCE   H. Pegrum

 

OFFICER:                Bob Whittome  (Town Clerk)

 

 

392.    APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

 

Apologies for absence were received from Councillors Miss O.D. Dunseath by reason of health and Miss M. Starling as a result of a personal emergency.

 

393.     CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES

 

Committee RESOLVED to approve the minutes of the meeting on 12th February 2008.

 

394.     DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

 

Councillors K. Avey and J.A. Smith declared prejudicial interests in respect of planning application EPF/0212/08 because they are trustees of Theydon Trust.

          

395.  REPORTS AND INFORMATION NOT REQUIRING A DECISION OF COMMITTEE

 

The Clerk advised Members of a response in respect of market trader parking from the County Council Highways Section.  Councillor Macrae had advised Members in regard to the Speak Easy bar, that enforcement action has taken place and resulted in a change to the sign.  However, there were still matters in respect of signage and the use which required action.  Councillor Murphy advised Members in respect of parking at the Epping Tube Station which suggested that Transport for London had no current intention to expand parking for tube commuters.

 

Councillor Murphy also advised Members in respect of the car parking review.  The County Council will carry out the review in consultation with the district council and the issue of placing double yellow lines at the corners of streets was apparently being considered.  The Clerk requested Members to separately pass a note of any new concerns or issues they may wish to raise in respect of the parking review so that the Clerk can include these in a summary letter in respect of the issues raised so far by the Town Council.

 

396.     PLANNING APPLICATIONS

 

Eight applications for planning permission were considered and the plans inspected. 

 

 

EPF/0101/08

 

25 Broadoaks

Mr & Mrs M Webb

Erection of a rear conservatory

 

Committee had no objection to this application.

 

 

EPF/169/08

 

23 Amesbury Road

Mr S. Bacon

Single storey side extension

Committee had no objection to this application.

 

 

EPF/0212/08

(Renewal of EPF/2158/02 with amendments)

 

Land to rear of Alms Houses, 17-21 Thornwood Road

Theydon Trust Ltd

Erection of a detached bungalow

Councillors Smith and Avey, having declared a prejudicial interest in this matter, left the chamber and the chair was taken during the discussion on this item by Councillor Hines (Town Mayor).

 

Committee had no objection to this application.

 

Councillors Smith and Avey rejoined Committee following discussion of this item  and Councillor Avey again took the chair.

 

 

EPF/0217/08

(Revised Appl)

 

1 Ashlyns Road

Mr & Mrs Mills

Loft conversion with rear dormer window

Committee had no objection to this application, however, it was felt that the design is still not pleasing or harmonious and committee request that the applicant and planning officers give this matter further attention to see if any modification may be possible that will improve the design by agreement.

 

 

EPF/0247/08

 

62A Centre Drive

Mr Adrian Worrod

Retention of pitched roof on existing flat roofed front dormer.

Committee had no objection to this application.

 

 

EPF/0279/08

 

Quality Hotel

(The Bell Hotel)

High Road

Hassan Somani

Outline application for the partial demolition of The Bell Inn and erection of new extension and Care Home.

Committee object to this application feeling that the proposals are an overdevelopment of th site and that the care home will impose a new burden on Epping’s infrastructure.  Committee were also concerned at the loss of hotel spaces.

 

 

EPF/0289/08

 

15 Beulah Road

Mr & Mrs D Daniell

Rebuild single storey side extension, pitched roof to existing first floor rear extension, extend front porch and bay window.

Committee had no objection to this application.

 

 

EPF/0299/08

 

40 Bury Road

Mr A McKay

Proposed dormer windows to front elevation

Committee had no objection to this application.

 

 

 

397.     ST MARGARET’S HOSPITAL OBJECTION - REQUEST FOR SUPPORT

 

Committee considered a request from a local group for support of their objection to the current planning proposals.  The group had requested a variety of different actions which would assist them and the Clerk advised Members that some of these items may require a section 137 expenditure.  Committee RESOLVED to delegate to the Clerk authority to comply or give assistance to the local interest group in so far as that assistance does not require section 137 expenditure and for an item to appear on the full Council agenda, if appropriate, to deal with other items.

 

Councillor Avey expressed concern at the quality of title to the land proposed for the hospital residential development and requested that this matter be investigated.  Committee recognise that this was not a planning matter, however, Committee did RESOLVE that the Clerk should send a freedom of information request to the PCT for information regarding the title to the land.

 

398.     ESSEX COUNTY COUNCIL – INTRODUCTION OF 1 APP & LOCAL VALIDATION CHECKLISTS – REQUIREMENTS FOR SUPPORTING INFORMATION SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION

 

Committee noted this information and AGREED to defer consideration of this matter until the next Committee meeting.

 

399.     EPPING FOREST DISTRICT COUNCIL – 1 APP APPLICATION FORMS & DRAFT VALIDATION CHECKLISTS

 

Committee noted this information and AGREED to defer consideration of this matter until the next Committee meeting.

 

400.     CIVIC AWARD

 

Committee considered nominations for this award and RESOLVED that Fat Face should be awarded the Civic Award for this year in recognition of its very fine refurbishment of a cherished local property.

 

401.     EFDC PLANNING DECISIONS

 

Committee NOTED  the decisions of Epping Forest District Council Area Planning Sub Committee East.

 

GRANTED:

 

EPF/2660/07

(TPO/26/94)

 

EPF/2676/07

EPF/2720/07

EPF/2723/07

EPF/2724/07

EPF/0004/08

 

 

 

 

REFUSED:

 

EPF/2328/07

(Revised Appl)

EPF/2634/07

EPF/2667/07